Hello, I am currently in the process of upgrading a group of machines to incorporate PLCs and HMIs. I am aware that utilizing a standard 255.255.255.0 subnet could result in limited space for future expansion. I am seeking advice on the advantages and disadvantages of using a single larger subnet versus implementing multiple smaller subnets with gateways. Alternatively, if there is a better solution available, I would appreciate any guidance on that as well. Thank you for your assistance.
Expanding subnets can lead to increased network traffic, potentially impacting I/O updates. To mitigate this, consider using a managed switch to regulate network traffic for individual devices, offering a simpler solution compared to managing multiple gateways.
For beginners, it is recommended to start with 192.168.1.x local IP addresses and 255.255.255.0 subnets. Subnets are often altered for job security reasons, but they are not as complex as they may seem. A subnet acts as a checkpoint between the IP address and Gateway. If you have the authority, you can easily connect different subnets in the future. However, if you lack control over this decision, it is a good idea to expand the subnets. When facing traffic challenges, it is important to inquire about the numbers involved. Automation equipment typically plays a small role in the vast expanse of TCPIP network.*importance varies based on context*
Subnets are commonly utilized to reduce broadcast traffic on a network, creating smaller broadcast domains. By dividing a network with 400 devices into four subnets of 100 devices each, the broadcast messages are limited to a smaller group of devices within each subnet. This can help improve network performance by preventing excessive broadcasts from impacting all devices. Adjusting the subnet mask can increase the maximum available devices on a network, although it results in creating larger broadcast domains. This modification is a cost-effective and simple solution that does not require additional hardware. However, ensuring that all users are using the modified mask can be challenging. It is important to manage broadcasts, as they are received by every device on a subnet and can affect network efficiency. Multicast messages, similar to broadcasts, can also be controlled with the right "Managed" ethernet switches. Without proper management, multicast messages can flood a network with unnecessary traffic, impacting overall performance. To prevent broadcasts from crossing subnets, devices can be segmented into different subnets. Communication between devices on different subnets can still occur with the use of a router or Layer 3 switch. Planning and communication with IT experts are essential when restructuring a network with multiple subnets to ensure seamless functionality.
By adjusting your subnet mask from 255.255.255.0 to 255.255.254.0, you can increase the number of available IPs from 253 to 509. Transitioning to a more restrictive subnet mask can improve network efficiency and prevent potential outages. For multiple subnets connected to a gateway, it is advisable to keep them on the same subnet for optimal performance, especially for remote I/O connections requiring low latency. Switching to a more stringent subnet mask can enhance network stability and prevent disruptions in case of gateway failures.
If you have 254 devices on a single network, consider physically segregating your network for better performance, especially when dealing with PLCs. While all PLCs and HMIs can share a network, it's beneficial to isolate their IO and Drives on local machine networks connected to the controlling PLC. This approach can prevent troubleshooting and maintenance issues that arise when all IO devices are placed on a plantwide IO network.
Hi, it's great to see you're thinking ahead in terms of potential expansion! Opting for a single larger subnet could certainly give you more space for additional PLCs and HMIs, but it may increase broadcast traffic, possibly impacting performance. Using multiple smaller subnets with gateways can help you better manage traffic by isolating each network segment. It can also improve security by limiting potential points of attack. However, it could make your network setup more complex. You could also consider subnetting based on the function or location of the machines, which could provide a good balance between manageability and future scalability. But again, selection largely depends on what you see as the key considerations in your setup: performance, manageability, security or scalability.
In my opinion, considering scalability and troubleshooting, using multiple smaller subnets may offer you more advantages. One significant advantage is segmentation and enhanced security. Cross-talk or "noise" from one machine won't affect others that are on different subnets, and if a device is compromised, it generally won't affect devices outside its subnet. Also, with smaller subnets, it is easier to manage local traffic and isolate issues as they arise. However, the caveat is that you need to manage multiple gateways, which might add some complexity to your network architecture. I would also suggest emphasizing subnetting when it's vital, like segregating process-sensitive machines from the overall network. These considerations, based on the specific nature of your use case, can help dictate the best approach.
✅ Work Order Management
✅ Asset Tracking
✅ Preventive Maintenance
✅ Inspection Report
We have received your information. We will share Schedule Demo details on your Mail Id.
Answer: Answer: One advantage of using a single large subnet is simplified network management as all devices are on the same network, making it easier to configure and troubleshoot.
Answer: Answer: A potential disadvantage of a single large subnet is the limitation of available IP addresses, which could restrict future expansion if the network grows beyond the subnet's capacity.
Answer: Answer: Using multiple smaller subnets with gateways allows for better network segmentation, improved security, and scalability as each subnet can accommodate a certain number of devices.
Answer: Answer: One disadvantage of multiple smaller subnets is the increased complexity of network configuration and routing compared to a single large subnet setup. Additionally, managing multiple subnets may require more resources and expertise.
Answer: Answer: Depending on the specific requirements of your industrial network, other solutions such as VLANs (Virtual Local Area Networks) or subnetting based on functional areas could offer a more efficient and secure network architecture. Consulting with a network specialist or industrial automation expert can help determine the best approach
Join hundreds of satisfied customers who have transformed their maintenance processes.
Sign up today and start optimizing your workflow.