Choosing Between Vision Systems and Laser Profilers for Fabric Quality Monitoring

Question:

We're developing an application that involves monitoring a fabric roll approximately 30 inches wide, traveling along a conveyor at speeds ranging from 50 to 80 yards per minute. Our goal is to detect any holes in the fabric. We've explored using a Keyence Vision System for this purpose, but we have concerns about the need for skilled technicians to operate and maintain it. While the Keyence system can save various fabric types for comparison, ongoing maintenance will still be necessary. During my research on Keyence, I came across the Laser Profiler technology and was intrigued by its capabilities. Given that the fabric is flat, I’m curious if anyone has successfully implemented a Laser Profiler for similar applications. It seems that the Profiler could easily identify any holes in the fabric as defects. Compared to the Vision System, the Laser Profiler appears to be simpler for operators to maintain, and less affected by fabric color, lighting conditions, or fabric thickness—such factors would be less of a concern. I would greatly appreciate any recommendations or insights from those with experience using a Laser Profiler in fabric detection. Thank you!

Top Replies

When operating at a speed of 80 yards per minute, which equals approximately 240 feet per minute or 4 feet per second, I have serious doubts about whether any vision system can effectively detect a hole at that pace. While I could be mistaken, it's essential to note that vision systems capture images in snapshots. Although I haven’t worked with these technologies in several years and may stand corrected, detecting a 30-inch hole at 4 feet per second seems challenging. Regardless of your choice of system, ensure that you have a demo unit available for real-world testing and be prepared to use some fabric for trial runs in genuine production conditions. Failing to do so may result in purchasing a system that, once installed, may not meet your needs. Consider how small the hole is that you want to detect and evaluate the system's camera and response time. A high pixel count in the camera is crucial for accurate detection. Additionally, since you will be working with fabric in a Class 3 environment, anticipate dealing with considerable fiber dust, which can pose challenges for any detection system. Programming will also be a critical aspect, so include in your purchase order the provision of having a technician present for eight hours a day over a two-week period to train multiple personnel. Best of luck with your decision! James

Here's a revised version of your text, optimized for readability, uniqueness, and SEO: "Consider installing a finely spaced light curtain, perhaps even two, positioned slightly offset. This setup allows beans to pass through the fabric seamlessly. If any beans are able to pass through, it indicates the presence of a hole."

Sawmill scanners are designed to rapidly analyze logs as they pass through the processing line. These advanced scanning systems can efficiently detect variations in log quality and dimensions, which significantly enhances productivity in lumber production. Additionally, there are various types of scanners available, including light curtain scanners that utilize photoelectric sensors to determine if any obstacles are present. For more information on these technologies, you can explore resources like JoeScan’s data sheets.

We specialize in defect detection for presses and labeling machines operating at speeds of 800 feet per minute, utilizing advanced line scan cameras. Our system features visually appealing graphics that allow for easy comparison with a gold standard reference image. Identifying defects, such as holes, becomes significantly easier when there’s a contrasting difference between the web and its background, enhancing the accuracy of our inspections.

Over a decade ago, I collaborated with a DVT system that effectively addressed the challenges you're facing with black fabrics used in tire production. At that time, the processing rates were significantly slower, and it required careful calibration by the integrator to achieve accurate "blob" detection. The design of the product featured intentional perforations that had to be disregarded, while any holes exceeding a specific pixel size needed to activate rejection mechanisms. To enhance performance, we utilized a specialized high-frequency fluorescent lamp strategically positioned behind the product, aligned with the cameras. In vision systems, lighting plays a crucial role. I recommend consulting with Cognex (the current owner of DVT) along with other industry experts. Arrange for them to visit your facility and provide tailored recommendations. I am confident that achieving your goals is possible, even at higher speeds, using multiple modern vision systems, but it is essential to implement the right strategies for optimal success.

More Replies →

Streamline Your Asset Management
See How Oxmaint Works!!

✅   Work Order Management

✅   Asset Tracking

✅   Preventive Maintenance

✅   Inspection Report

We have received your information. We will share Schedule Demo details on your Mail Id.

You must be a registered user to add a comment. If you've already registered,
sign in. Otherwise, register and sign in.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

FAQ: Answer: When choosing between a Vision System and a Laser Profiler, consider the following factors:

Answer: - Operator Skill Level: Vision Systems may require more skilled technicians for setup and maintenance. - Environmental Conditions: Laser Profilers are less affected by changes in lighting and

Ready to Simplify Maintenance?

Join hundreds of satisfied customers who have transformed their maintenance processes.
Sign up today and start optimizing your workflow.

Request Demo  â†’