Curious about which refineries are involved in Solomon Associates' benchmarking studies? Wondering where your refinery falls in terms of performance compared to others? Discover the advantages of participating in refinery benchmarking with Solomon Associates.
Several years ago, I was responsible for organizing the participation of refineries in the Solomon studies for a global oil company. Solomon Associates (SAI) conducts these studies annually, alternating between the USA in even years and the rest of the world in odd years. Each study includes around 150-200 refineries, with the specific locations kept confidential by SAI. As a result, only SAI can provide information on the participants in each study, including details on who ranks in the top quartile or is considered a pacesetter. However, what is available is the performance data for each refinery, including metrics such as energy consumption, manpower utilization, maintenance and operating costs, and conversion efficiency. SAI employs a normalization process in their analysis, measuring all process units in equivalent distillation capacity (EDC) to allow for comparisons between simple and complex refineries. They also make adjustments for shutdown cycles and maintenance cost allocations to ensure consistency across different accounting practices. This approach creates a level playing field for all participants in the study.
In order to achieve a fair competition, companies strive to level the playing field. While working for a multinational oil company, I have come across the concept of Solomon surveys, which aim to benchmark participants. It's interesting to note that even within the same unit of a refinery, engineers may produce different survey results. This leads to questions about the standardization of responses among all participants. Furthermore, the Solomon Report explicitly advises against making organizational changes based on comparisons, as it can lead to detrimental actions like unnecessary layoffs. It serves as a reminder that blindly following benchmarks may not lead to the desired outcome. To truly achieve success, one must understand the unique qualities and strategies that have brought others to their current position. Remember, it's about the journey, not just the destination. - Kim Williams
It is recommended to proceed with caution before implementing any organizational or operational changes based solely on benchmarking comparisons. While benchmarking can provide valuable insights, its validity is often limited to a specific timeframe, particularly during self-assessments. Best practices and benchmarking data, especially in the field of maintenance, can offer useful indicators. However, be wary of blindly following practices that may not be suitable for your specific situation and could potentially result in negative outcomes. It is important to carefully consider the recommendations of the Standards of Auditing Institute (SAI) before making any decisions.
What advantages does benchmarking offer even if no changes are planned to be implemented? Explore the benefits of engaging in benchmarking initiatives without the intention of making adjustments.
When it comes to benchmarking, the key is not to simply replicate, but to truly comprehend the process. Consider a scenario where Company A has made consistent improvements over the years and is now at the top of its industry. It would not be practical for Company B, which has not focused on improvements, to directly adopt Company A's current organizational structure and workforce allocation in hopes of achieving the same success. Company B must instead analyze and understand the steps taken by Company A to reach its current position. It is crucial to follow the same path, not just imitate the end result. By understanding and replicating the path taken by successful companies, we can expedite our own journey towards success. Just like in algebra class, where showing your work was essential for scoring full marks, in the business world, understanding the process is key to achieving desired outcomes. Additionally, in benchmarking studies, it's important to consider economies of scale. For instance, the operation of a 200,000 barrel-per-day crude unit may not necessarily require significantly more staff compared to a 50,000 barrel-per-day unit. In fact, a newer 200,000 bpd unit might even operate more efficiently with fewer employees. These intricate details should be carefully examined when embarking on improvement initiatives based on benchmarking. By comprehending both the successful company's system and path, as well as our own system and goals, we can chart a successful course forward using the lessons learned from others.
I've been part of Solomon Associates' benchmarking studies before and I found the insights very valuable. It was especially eye-opening to see how our refinery's performance stacked up against others on a global scale. The benchmarking process really shone a light on our blind spots and helped us to critically evaluate and improve our strategies and practices. Highly recommended for any refinery wanting a comprehensive understanding of their standing in the industry.
I've personally seen the advantages of benchmarking studies with Solomon Associates in my own work in the refinery sector. It’s incredible to be able to understand where you stand in comparison to industry standards. Plus, the insights we got were comprehensive and actionable, which was particularly useful in formulating our strategy moving forward. Highly recommend participating if you haven't done so already.
I've had experience with Solomon Associates' benchmarking studies at my refinery, and it's an excellent tool to compare our performance with others globally. It helps us identify areas of improvement objectively. You'd be surprised at the insights you gain, and the competitive edge it provides is invaluable. It's not just about knowing where you stand, but also understanding how to enhance operational efficiency based on real-world data.
It's great to see interest in Solomon Associates' benchmarking studies! They cover a wide range of refineries across the globe, allowing participants to compare various metrics like efficiency and profitability against industry leaders. Joining their benchmarking program can provide invaluable insights into operational performance, highlight areas for improvement, and even foster networking opportunities with peers. Plus, understanding where your refinery stands can lead to targeted strategies that drive better results in such a competitive market!
That's a great question! Solomon Associates conducts benchmarking studies with a wide range of refineries globally, including both large integrators and smaller, independent facilities. Participating in these studies can provide valuable insights into performance metrics, efficiency, and best practices, helping refineries identify improvement areas and optimize operations. It’s really eye-opening to see where you stand in comparison to peers and learn from the top performers in the industry!
✅ Work Order Management
✅ Asset Tracking
✅ Preventive Maintenance
✅ Inspection Report
We have received your information. We will share Schedule Demo details on your Mail Id.
Answer: - Solomon Associates' benchmarking studies focus on comparing the performance of refineries in various aspects such as efficiency, productivity, and operational excellence.
Answer: - By participating in Solomon Associates' benchmarking studies, your refinery can gain insights into its performance compared to industry peers, identify areas for improvement, and implement best practices to enhance operational efficiency.
Answer: - Refineries are selected based on specific criteria such as size, location, operational processes, and willingness to participate. Solomon Associates ensures a diverse representation of refineries to provide comprehensive benchmarking insights.
Answer: - Solomon Associates leverages its extensive industry expertise, robust data analytics, and proven methodologies to deliver accurate and actionable benchmarking insights. Participating refineries can trust the credibility and reliability of the benchmarking studies conducted by Solomon Associates.
Join hundreds of satisfied customers who have transformed their maintenance processes.
Sign up today and start optimizing your workflow.