Maximizing Relevance: Rethinking Birthday Listings in the AMP Events Section

Question:

Thinking about removing the birthday display on the website. It is unclear if the birthday listings are actually helpful. With 53667 members, there are on average 147 birthdays celebrated each day. This makes it difficult to find other important events. As John Adams famously said in the play 1776, "Does anybody care, is anybody there?" Perhaps it's time to prioritize more relevant information on the site.

Top Replies

I agree with John's perspective on listing birthdays for all the members in the community. It's impractical and unnecessary, as most people do not pay attention to them. While it's important to foster a sense of community, we should avoid turning this platform into just another social networking site. Let's focus on what sets us apart and provides value to our users.

Unlike Facebook, birthdays aren't a big deal on this forum. - Walt Improved, Unique, SEO-friendly Text: On this forum, birthdays are not a top priority unlike on Facebook. - Walt

We value your feedback and understand your concerns, but we want to experiment with including birthdays for a while to enhance communication and connection within our community. While we understand that our platform is not Facebook, we believe there is value in acknowledging and celebrating birthdays. If you prefer not to see birthdays on the calendar, you can easily view other events by clicking the Calendar Link, selecting CRL events from the drop-down menu, or subscribing to iCal. Additionally, we are in the process of planning a major website redesign to make it more responsive across all devices by September/October 2015. Your feedback on birthdays has been duly noted and will be taken into consideration during our planning discussions. Stay tuned for updates on our progress.

Looking for a way to view your calendar without birthdays on a consistent basis? Simply follow these steps: 1) Click the Calendar Link, 2) Select CRL events from the drop-down menu, or 3) Subscribe to iCal. These changes should be permanent unless you exit and re-enter, which will revert back to the default birthday list.

It's important to remember, John, that this forum is more than just a community service - it's a business. With a focus on increasing page views and ad clicks, expanding the user base is essential to drive revenue growth. However, finding a balance is crucial to avoid alienating the core contributors who have made this platform successful. What if the top 40 or 50 posters decided to take their conversations elsewhere? It's a possibility that needs to be considered.

I think you've raised a valid point. While the birthday feature might incite a sense of community, when the numbers are so high, the feature loses its charm and purpose. Perhaps, this space could be used to highlight members' achievements or showcase upcoming events which would not only deliver more relevant information but also foster a stronger sense of community and engagement.

I completely agree with rethinking the utility of birthday displays. While it's a nice gesture, with such a large member base, the information may lose its significance. Perhaps, we could incorporate personalized birthday notifications instead, which are still celebratory but not cluttering the site. This will allow us to prioritize and highlight other crucial events. However, this discussion should be open to everyone to maintain a democratic website environment and see how others feel about this change.

I totally agree with your point of view. I hardly notice the birthdays because there are just so many every day, and they end up overshadowing other significant events or updates. Maybe we can shift the birthday notifications to a dedicated section to clean up the main feed, or even consider personalizing it, so users only see birthdays of their close connections or frequently interacted members. That seems like a more balanced approach.

More Replies →

Streamline Your Asset Management
See How Oxmaint Works!!

✅   Work Order Management

✅   Asset Tracking

✅   Preventive Maintenance

✅   Inspection Report

We have received your information. We will share Schedule Demo details on your Mail Id.

To add a comment, please sign in or register if you haven't already..   

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

FAQ: 1. Why is there a discussion about removing birthday listings on the website?

Answer: - The discussion is centered around the relevance of displaying birthday listings with a large number of members on the website, making it challenging to find other important events due to the high frequency of birthdays celebrated each day.

FAQ: 2. How many birthdays are celebrated on average each day with 53667 members?

Answer: - With 53667 members, there are approximately 147 birthdays celebrated on average each day, which contributes to the consideration of whether the birthday listings are truly beneficial.

FAQ: 3. What is the proposed rationale for reconsidering the birthday display on the website?

Answer: - The proposal is to prioritize more relevant information on the site by potentially removing the birthday listings, as highlighted by the quote referencing the need to assess if anybody cares or if anybody finds the birthday listings useful.

Ready to Simplify Maintenance?

Join hundreds of satisfied customers who have transformed their maintenance processes.
Sign up today and start optimizing your workflow.

Request Demo  â†’